The Best Organic Mattresses of 2024
When you spend most of your life sleeping, the material you lie on matters. Organic mattresses promise a cleaner, more sustainable alternative to the conventional foam and innerspring beds that dominate the market. In this guide we distill the findings of over 50 mattress reviews, focusing on the top 10 organic models that combine comfort, durability, and environmental responsibility.
Top 10 Best Organic Mattresses
| # | Mattress | Type | Main Materials | Firmness | Trial | Certification | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Birch Luxe | Hybrid | Organic latex, organic wool, cotton, coils | Medium-firm | 100 nights | GOLS, GOTS, Oeko-Tex | 25 yrs |
| 2 | Avocado Green | Hybrid | Latex, wool, cotton, coils | Firm / Medium / Plush | 365 nights | GOTS, GOLS | 25 yrs |
| 3 | Naturepedic EOS | Latex | Organic cotton, wool, latex | Extra-firm to Plush | 100 nights | GOLS, GOTS | 25 yrs |
| 4 | S&S Organic | Hybrid | Latex, wool, cotton, pocketed coils | Medium-firm | 365 nights | GOLS, GOTS | 15 yrs |
| 5 | Saatva Zenhaven | Natural latex | Latex, wool, cotton | Medium-firm | 365 nights | GOTS, GOLS | Lifetime |
| 6 | Awara Premier | Hybrid | Latex, wool | Medium-firm | 365 nights | GOLS | Lifetime |
| 7 | Awara Natural | Hybrid | Latex, wool | Firm | 365 nights | GOLS | 10 yrs |
| 8 | Woolroom Wooly | Hybrid | British merino wool, nanocoils, microcoils | Medium / Firm | 100 nights | Woolmark | 10 yrs |
| 9 | Coyuchi REM | Hybrid | Latex, wool, cotton | Medium-firm | 100 nights | GOTS | 25 yrs |
| 10 | My Green Kiwi | Hybrid | Latex, wool, cotton | Medium-firm | 365 nights | GOTS | 20 yrs |
> Scott Gilbertson: ‘We bring each bed into our homes for at least seven nights, often longer-in many cases, years longer-of real-life testing.’
> Julia Forbes: ‘Pure latex mattresses retain heat; adding wool layers can make them as breathable as innersprings.’
These models span the firmness spectrum and price points, but all share rigorous certifications that guarantee low levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and other toxins.
What Makes a Mattress Organic?
Organic certification is more than a buzzword. The Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS) verifies that the latex is derived from rubber trees grown without harmful chemicals, while the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) covers cotton, wool, and other textiles. The Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certifies the finished product is free of toxic substances such as heavy metals or flame retardants.
> Scott Gilbertson: ‘Organic mattresses exclude fire retardants. Wool, a natural material, is inherently fire-resistant, so these beds meet flammability standards without added chemicals.’
Because industrial processing can introduce contaminants, most manufacturers list the percentage of certified organic latex in their foam. A 95 % GOLS rating is the highest attainable; the remaining 5 % represents necessary processing agents.
How Source Tests Mattresses
The review team doesn’t rely on lab simulations or anonymous surveys. Instead, they sleep on each mattress for a minimum of seven nights, often extending the test over months or years. They evaluate:
- Firmness – How the bed feels for side, stomach, and back sleepers.
- Edge support – How well the mattress holds shape at the corners.
- Motion transfer – Whether partner movements disturb you.
- Cooling – How the bed regulates temperature.
- Company factors – Reputation, ordering experience, shipping time, trial, and warranty.
> Scott Gilbertson: ‘We bring each bed into our homes for at least seven nights, often longer-in many cases, years longer-of real-life testing.’
After testing, every mattress is donated, allowing the team to give back while clearing space for the next model.
Buying Tips for Organic Mattresses
| Tip | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Know your sleeper type | Side, stomach, back, or combination sleepers prefer different support levels. |
| Pick the right firmness | Firmness is subjective; test options to avoid future discomfort. |
| Watch temperature | Natural latex tends to trap heat; wool layers help keep cool for hot sleepers. |
| Check the trial | A sleep trial lets you return the mattress if it doesn’t meet expectations. |
| Compare warranties | A 25-year warranty signals confidence in durability; avoid models capped at 10 yrs. |
| Wait for sales | Mattresses frequently go on sale; patience can save money. |
> Julia Forbes: ‘More expensive doesn’t mean better. Organic mattresses aren’t cheap, but you can get a good, eco-friendly night’s sleep without breaking the bank.’
Durability and Longevity
Higher-quality natural materials outperform synthetic alternatives, especially when it comes to sagging. The review team found that proper foundation support is essential to preserve the mattress’s shape over time.
> Scott Gilbertson: ‘Higher-quality natural materials like those in the mattresses featured here outperform synthetic alternatives, particularly when it comes to sagging. The best way to prevent sagging is to have adequate support from a good foundation.’
Price and Value
While organic mattresses are pricier than conventional options, the long-term durability and lower chemical exposure often justify the investment. For example, the Avocado Green Hybrid is priced at about $2,000 for a queen, and its 365-night trial plus 25-year warranty make it a solid long-term choice.
Zero Waste and Sustainability
Nothing is truly zero-waste, but a long-lasting mattress reduces the need to replace it every few years. By choosing a durable organic bed, you cut down on the environmental cost of manufacturing, shipping, and disposing of mattresses.
Flammability and Health
Organic mattresses use natural wool that is fire-resistant; synthetic materials require flame retardants. This difference means that organic beds are not only cleaner but also safer for families with children or pets.
> Scott Gilbertson: ‘Because modern mattresses are an all-in-one proposition, many manufacturers discourage the use of a box spring, as it may damage the bed.’
Final Thoughts
Organic mattresses offer a compelling blend of comfort, health benefits, and environmental stewardship. By paying attention to certifications, trial periods, and warranties, you can find a bed that suits your sleep style and values.
> Source remains committed to testing new mattresses and donating the old ones, ensuring that everyone has access to a good night’s sleep.
